Israeli Opposition to US – Iran Nuclear Negotiations

Netanyahu’s Reaction

As negotiations between American and Iranian ambassadors within recent months have begun to show signs of progress towards a diplomatic deal, Israel has continually voiced their “vehement opposition” to the preliminary agreement. Netanyahu has been cited, saying that the establishment of such a deal would not block Iran from acquiring a nuclear arsenal, but instead pave the path for them. The possibility of a nuclear strike upon the Jewish state appears unlikely to many and the threats are considered rhetoric, and yet Netanyahu and his government appear incredibly adamant in their effort to cease the establishment of any kind of deal. Israeli Minister of Intelligence Yuval Steinitz, on the issue, was quoted saying, “if we have no choice, we have no choice. . . . The military option is on the table.” Such a conflict within the Middle-East, between two regional powers, would be catastrophic and the likelihood of the United States being dragged into this fighting is definitely a possibility. Netanyahu also expressed concern regarding the lifting of economic sanctions on Iran. The Israeli leader addressed how the bolstering of the Iranian economy, through the lifting of sanctions could allow Iran surplus capital “to pump up their terror machine worldwide.” Instead, Netanyahu encouraged the intensification of economic sanctions to force Iran to give up more of its nuclear abilities before any deal is finalized.

I believe that conflict between Israel and Iran plays to great of a role within American foreign policy in the Middle-East. Iran was once a powerful ally of the United States under the reign of Mohammad Reza Shah and the Pahlavi dynasty. If warmer relations between the US and Iran will ever return to such a state, the best way to do this would be the lifting of economic sanctions. The Iranian population is incredibly young; 60% of the country is under the age of 30. The demographics of the nation denote a particularly large youth bulge and consequently the middle class of the Persian state has increased substantially. The key to a stable and prosperous state is a strong and healthy middle class. Iran maintains a large enough population, but unfortunately, the Iranian people currently suffer for notably high inflation rates, high unemployment and the over appreciation of the Iranian dollar due the state’s dependence on a single export commodity – oil. Should economic sanctions on Iran be lifted by the US, the economic conditions within Iran would surely improve, which would lead to significantly increased stability and prosperity within the region. The likelihood of Iran then turning its attention towards the destruction of Israel would then be incredibly unlikely. The foreign investment and surplus capital pouring its way into the Iranian economy through the lifting of economic sanctions would immediately be withdrawn, should Iran show signs of aggression towards Israel. I believe that should Israel choose to pursue military action against the state of Iran, the implications will be cataclysmic and surely felt throughout the entirety of the Middle-Eastern region.

Islamic State Aggression Within Iraq

Initial Invasion of Anbar

Thousands of families within the Anbar province of Iraq gathered their possessions and fled their homes following recent suggestions that the Islamic State may be making coming advances towards Ramadi, the capital of Anbar province. The scores of displaed families have been forced out of their homes and the loss of Iraq’s western city of Ramadi to Islamist forces would be catastrophic. US-led airstrikes have continued against the militant extremists, but this has done little to suppress their advance. Iraqi military officials went on to say that securing Ramadi, along with the rest of Anbar province, is critical in Iraq’s government against the Islamic State. Before Mosul can be retaken by Iraqi military forces, Anbar province must be secured.

Progress Made

Following weeks of back and forth fighting between the Iraqi military and ISIS militants, military officials now claim to have begun making progress against the Islamic State within the region. “Defense Minister Khalid al-Obeidi said on Iraqi television that the army has achieved “90 percent” of its objectives in the town of Garma, between Baghdad and the IS-held city of Fallujah.” However, the progress has not been made without significant losses on the Iraqi side. Many Iraqi soldiers have lost their lives combating the Islamic State’s forces within the region in an effort to reclaim Anbar province.

Islamic State’s Evil Felt Elsewhere in Iraq

The atrocities that the Islamic States has committed within Iraq is unfortunately not exclusive to only the Anbar province. Last June, the Islamist radicals maintained control over Tikrit, the former seat of power for the former Iraqi dictator, Saddam Hussein. During the time of the Islamic State occupation, approximately 1,700 Shiite soldiers went missing from their posts at nearby Camp Speicher. Now, the mass graves have begun to be uncovered as the endless piles of bodies show signs of bondage and gunshot wounds through the skull.

Personal Sentiment 

The Iraqi invasion of 2003 launched by American forces sparked a series of chaotic conflicts within the region that the country has not yet been able to recover from and so long as groups like the Islamic State exist, peace will never be realized. The crimes against humanity committed by the Islamic State over the course of these past few years are unforgivable and deserving of unwavering retaliation. Unfortunately, it appears as though the powers of the world seem incredibly hesitant to involve their own forces within the affairs of the Middle-East. Perhaps the risk of involving themselves further within the region’s conflicts is unsavory and worth allowing the Iraqi and Syrian citizens to be continually harassed and terrorized by the militant forces. Unfortunately, should foreign powers continue their neutrality within the conflicts of the Middle-East, I fear that the Iraq and Syrian forces may eventually fall to the Islamic State, allowing the organization to maintain control over much more significant swaths of land and allowing for them to become a much more global actor.

Saudi Airstrikes Continue on Yemeni Capital

Fighting has erupted within the state of Yemen, escalating significantly within recent weeks. Earlier this year, the Yemeni President Abdu Rabbu Mansour Hadi lost control of his government to a coalition of Houthi rebels. Yemen is one of the poorest nations within the region and has been a host to severe infighting within recent times. The Houthi rebels support former President Ali Abdullah Saleh and have made significant advances with Yemen to rest control over the state. In an effort to retaliate against the Houthi rebels and to restore the regime of President Hadi, the Saudi Arabian military has begun to conduct a series of airstrikes upon the Houthi-controlled Yemeni capital of Sana’a. Air raids, naval shelling and ground fighting have run rampant within Yemen as the Iranian Houthi rebels worked to retain the control that they now have. The fighting within Yemen is partly attributable to religious division. While Saudi Arabia maintains a predominantly Sunni population and asserts itself as one of the regional powers within the Middle-East, Iran, another regional power, maintains a predominantly Shiite Muslim population. By extension, the Houthi rebels are primarily Shiite, and the Saudi resistance towards Houthi expansion could be a reaction against the spread of Shiism. Yemen is located just south of the Saudi Arabian border upon the Arabian peninsula and these airstrikes may be an effort to suppress a Shiite government from coming to power within the region. Abu Dhabi’s Crown Prince Sheikh Mohammed bin Zayed al-Nahyan recently expressed his commitment to the Saudi coalition in their effort to reclaim the throne for President Hadi.

When considering the whole Yemen situation, I cannot help but see a comparison between this conflict and the Cold War. Perhaps this is a gross oversimplification of the issue at hand, but I feel as though similarities may be drawn in some regards. During the Cold War, two world powers (the United States and the Soviet Union) both worked against each other in a global effort to spread their own particular ideologies and ensure that their sphere on influence was greater than that of the opposition. In terms of the escalating Yemeni conflict, Iran and Saudi Arabia are both regional power which both seek to maximize their own interpretations of Islam. Sunnis represent vast majority of the world’s Muslims, while Shiite only account for between 10-13% of Muslims worldwide. Both the Persian state and the Saudi state are major actors and the spread of aggressive opposition Muslims anywhere within their immediate spheres of influence could easily be interpreted the wrong way. The result appears to be a type of proxy war occurring within the politically unstable Yemen region.

Assad’s War

Since the advent of the Arab Spring in early 2011, regimes across the Middle-East have had to contend with insurgencies and rebel organizations. Syria is one of these countries, but unlike Iraq, Libya and Egypt, Bashar al-Assad and his regime still assert control over vast swaths of the Syrian landscape. The government in Damascus remains well-fortified and in control of other major regions within the state. However, within recent months, Syrian rebels have made significant advances against the incumbent regime. Key cities are being lost to insurgents and now belong to the opposition. Bashar al-Assad and his armed forces have been able to steadily repel the encroaching forces for the past couple years of the war and this is the first time that significant advances are being made on either side. The center of Assad’s government in Damascus still remain in control and well defended. The cities that were lost to the rebels within recent months are located around the periphery of the state where supply lines and support from Assad’s routes are stretched thinly. There had also been little US intervention within the civil war recently due to American attention being diverted towards other matters within the Middle-East such as the rise of the Islamic State and the nuclear deals with Iran.

To me, the idea of Bashar al-Assad losing control over the entirety of his nation could very well be extremely disastrous and the implications of such an event could be ruinous. The deposition of Bashar al-Assad and his regime could lead to the complete loss of social order within the region. Without Assad and his forces present in the region, the Islamic State will be free to increase their expansion into Syrian territory.

Law and Order: Egypt Edition

Ever since the dawn of the Arab Spring in early 2011, which prompted the deposition of Hosni Mubarak in Egypt, the Egyptian nation has found itself in a perpetual state of chaos and political upheaval. Immediately after Mubarak’s regime was toppled, other political factions began their quest for political dominance. The Muslim Brotherhood was particularly successful, who established Mohamed Morsi as president. Soon after his establishment as president, Morsi was deposed and the Muslim Brotherhood was outlawed throughout Egypt, now considered a terrorist organization. Following the capture of Morsi, he was tried and prosecuted within Egyptian courts. He will now be serving 20 years within prison.

It appears as though the Arab Spring has resulted in more chaos and destruction than originally anticipated; a classic example of “the devil you know versus the devil you don’t”. Although the dictators of the Middle-East were tyrannical and oppressive, since the deposition of these leaders, order has been lost. Gaddafi, Hussein,  and Mubarak are all examples of leaders who have lost control and now the countries that they formerly held control over are lawless and the regions have lost civil order.

Militant Muslims Versus Islamist Extremists

For months, the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria has steadily been gaining territory and with the recent declaration of Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi as the global caliphate has raised alarm not only among prominent global and regional actors, but surprisingly, within other jihadi groups as well. Back in July of 2014, the Taliban, the primary jihadi organization within Afghanistan and Pakistan, posted a warning on their official website, warning the Islamic State, indirectly. The post did not explicitly address al-Baghdadi and has militant state, but heavily implied their disdain towards their recent actions and operations. The Taliban warned against extremism and declared that a jihadi council should be marshaled to organize action. They went on to then condemn the group’s distrust for other Muslims.

Since then, tensions between the two terrorist organizations have only escalated. Both groups have now declared jihad against one another. The members of ISIS believe that the Afghani insurgents owe their loyalty to al-Baghdadi, their Caliph. Al-Baghdadi has gone on to refer to the Taliban leader, Mullah Mohammad Omar, as “a fool and illiterate warlord”. Members within the Taliban recognize the Islamic State as drastically too extreme and do not properly treat other Muslims with the same respect. However, there have been Islamic State sympathizers within Afghanistan and Pakistan as well. Members have previously expresses their agreement with the Islamic State militants and their methods and how they have gone on too conduct their operations within Iraq and Syria. They believe that the bold initiative and scope that they aspire too is an exemplar model for what the Taliban should aspire to.

It is surprising that two militant Islamic groups within the Middle-East would find such disagreement between them that they resort to all out war. Both groups have resorted to extreme interpretations of Islamic law to further their nefarious political agendas and both organizations advocate for the establishment of a completely Islamic state. However, the two organizations do find their differences within how they implement their operations and their treatment of Muslim minorities, such as the Shiites. The Islamic State is a primarily Sunni Muslim organization have subsequently treated Shiite Muslims with hostility and aggression. With this declaration of war between the two groups, one can only hope that the two groups will be able to suppress the growth of each powers. The Islamic State has been steadily encroaching upon Iraqi and Syrian land for months. Perhaps the jihad between the two will be able to weaken the state.

Progress with Iran – US Nuclear Deals

The international community was shocked recently with the announcement that progress was being made to secure an agreement between American and Iranian ambassadors. The two nations have been at odds for decades and the conflict over Iran’s nuclear capabilities is only the latest in a long and contentious past between the two. The United States has historically maintained close relations with Israel, who, in turn, holds much animosity towards the Iranian state. Iran and Israel frequently swap threats and condemn each other. When the prospect of the Iran weaponizing nuclear energy surfaced, alarm was raised throughout the international community and negotiations began between the US and Iran, with hopes that Iran may limit its uranium enrichment to the point that its nuclear energy programs will be confined to domestic use. Now progress is being made following several months of stalemate between American and Iranian ambassadors.

In return for Iran limiting uranium enrichment and other production restrictions, the United States is expected to relieve Iran of a series of economic sanctions that were imposed to deter nuclear production. Since then, foreign investors have been pouring into the Persian state to begin exploring potential investment opportunities. This would be extremely beneficial to the Iranian state; their economy is in shambles and the regime’s attempts to alleviate economic destitution have been met with very little success. The current economy in Iran suffers from high unemployment, high inflation and extreme dependency on the exportation of one single commodity – oil. With the reduction of sanctions against the Iranians, the economy would once again be able to openly conduct business with the largest economy in the world and her allies. Although, this would not be the perfect solution to ameliorate all of Iran’s fiscal problems, this would certainly generate steady economic growth and may potentially allow for the diversification of the Iranian economy.

When reviewing the progress between the Iran and American negotiators, I was happy to hear that warmer relations between the two states could potentially be on the horizon. Although heavy criticism of the US and animosity exists within Iran, this hatred usually manifests itself within the older citizens of Iran; those who were alive and active during the 1979 revolution. Among the younger citizens in Iran, secularism, westernization and liberalism are all growing increasingly attractive and I like to believe that within coming decades, the currently hostile regime may slowly alter to a more friendly government. Critics of Iran who seek to impose harsher restrictions upon them and to pursue more aggressive action often cite their hostility towards our ally, Israel. Personally, I believe that it is hypocritical to restrict a regime from acquiring nuclear power, when we ourselves maintain one of the largest nuclear stockpiles in the world. The likelihood of Iran deploying nuclear armaments against Israel is highly unlikely. Should they pursue such actions, the combined wrath of the American army, navy and air force would reign down upon the Persian state and the nation would be decimated. I see little reason for Iran to actively seek military engagements with the US or Israel.

Tough Times For Yemen

Houthi Takeover

The Yemeni government has officially been dissolved and Houthi rebels now assert political dominance throughout Sana’a, the current capital of Yemen. The insurgent movement now suggests a two-year transitional government blueprint to lead their country as the nation’s leadership is passed on. However, rival political factions criticize the Houthi offer and finding a consensus among Yemen’s political leadership has proven to be more difficult than originally anticipated. The Houthi takeover has been coupled with heavy criticism and opposition from not only other Yemeni political organizations but from within the group itself. A former senior member of the movement, Ali al-Bukhaiti condemned the Houthis, stating that, “The Houthis will never be able to control Yemen just because they control San’a…their supporters are limited to certain areas of the country. They have yet to understand that and this will cause their collapse.”

Political Upheaval Upsetting Yemeni Oil

Not only has the Houthi rebellion sparked unrest and disorder within the country’s government, but within the nation’s economy as well; more specifically, the petro-sector. As the country deals with the transition of power, many oil companies such as Occidental Petroleum Corp, whose presence has been established throughout Yemen for almost three decades, have evacuated staff and oil patches are now severely underworked. Other oil countries have taken more drastic measures such as relinquishing their rights to oil patches entirely. Oil has provided Yemen with significant revenue for many years now, but the diminishment of Yemen’s oil production certainly does not bode well for the future of the nation’s government and people.

Arming Up The Saudis

Saudi Arabia Becomes World’s Largest Arms Importer

Recents analyses suggest that Saudi Arabia has officially surpassed India in terms of the importation of military and defense equipment. The global trade of defense equipment accounts for a immense amounts of capital and due to the escalating tensions within the Middle-East, the Saudis have allocated money towards the building of a strong, competent and technologically-advanced armed forces. The combined defense imports between both the United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia totaled more than all of Western Europe’s. This increased importation has proven to be significantly beneficial to the United States, who currently ranks as the number one exporter of defense equipment around the world. This growing Saudi demand for American defense equipment could potentially develop into a synergistic relationship between the two states.

Islamic State Finds Support From African Islamists

Boko Haram

When considering Islamist extremism and jihadist terror attacks throughout the world, many would likely assume it to be occurring within the confines of the Middle-East. Unfortunately, this is far from the actual truth and inspired Muslim radicals outside of the Middle-East have successfully prompted extremist movements within Sub-Saharan Africa in recent years. One of the most infamously prominent of these groups is the terrorist organization of Boko Haram. The official name for the group is “Jama’atu Ahlis Sunna Lidda’awati wal-Jihad”, which translates directly to “People Committed to the Propagation of the Prophet’s Teachings and Jihad”. Boko Haram has been the source of much chaos and disorder throughout Nigeria since its founding, claiming that all muslims should abstain from western political and social activity; this includes voting in elections, wearing shirts and trousers, and receiving a secular education. The Boko Haram organization enforces a strict understanding of Islam and also regards the the Nigerian government to be run by non-believers, although the current president of Nigeria is, in fact, a muslim.

The devices employed by Boko Haram to further political, religious and social objectives are very similar to those displayed by groups such as ISIS. Military campaigns led by the group surfaced back in 2009 and since then, the insurgencies have only escalated. Attacks continue throughout Nigeria and suicide-bombings remain prevalent. Extreme acts of brutality follow the group where it goes; beheadings, mass-killings and abduction continuing on against religious and ethnic minorities.

An Alliance Between Two Evils

The central goal of the Boko Haram terrorist organization is to reject western practices, in favor of more traditional Islamic ones and to establish a unified Muslim state within the world. This resulted in Boko Haram’s interests aligning very closely with that of the ISIS terrorist organization. ISIS stands for the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria, and shares similar aspirations with Boko Haram in terms of an anti-western and anti-American Islamic State. Prior to this week, Boko Haram leaders has expressed support for the actions and objectives of ISIS, but now they have officially declared their allegiance to the terrorist sect. Abu-Bakr al-Baghdadi, the current leader of ISIS, has often declared himself as caliph; the spiritual and political leader of all Muslims. In a message from the leader of Boko Haram, he stated, “We announce our allegiance to the caliph… and will hear and obey in times of difficulty and prosperity.” This clearly poses a threat to enemies of the terrorist factions; as the cooperation between both ISIS and Boko Haram may pose a much larger threat to peace and stability throughout not only the Middle-East, but in Africa as well.